- Fundamental Flaw: Assumption that more IP translates to more innovation.
- IP as Means, Not End: Fails to appreciate IP as a tool, not an end in itself.
- Knowledge Flow: IP may not work well in certain technology sectors where free knowledge flow is better.
- Informal Economy: Superimposing formal IP regime in informal economy may do more harm.
- Public Domain: Apprehension about enlargement of protection to objects in public domain.
- Lack of Specifics: Policy lacks specifics and may not be enough to foster innovation.
- Contradiction with Patent Law: Contradicts philosophy of “minimalism” in Indian patent law.